Arguments made in hospital recall petition

Whether a petition to recall the president of the Valley Medical Center Board of Commissioners would move forward was argued Thursday for about an hour, but the judge indicated he wouldn’t issue his ruling until Tuesday (yesterday).

  • Friday, May 30, 2008 2:52pm
  • News


Whether a petition to recall the president of the Valley Medical Center Board of Commissioners would move forward was argued Thursday for about an hour, but the judge indicated he wouldn’t issue his ruling until Tuesday (yesterday).

King County Superior Judge Michael Trickey presided over what’s known as a “sufficiency hearing”.

Chris Clifford of Renton filed the petition against board President Don Jabcobson. Clifford stated that Jacobson had violated the Open Public Meetings Act and abused his power as president of the board by circumventing its bylaws.

Jacobson’s attorney, Scott Johnson, argued that the entirety of the recall petition was without merit and not worth wasting the court’s time discussing.

David Berman, an attorney from the firm of Perkins Cooie retained to represent the hospital, was granted a motion to intervene on behalf of Valley but was limited to narrow scope of argument.

Clifford pointed to the discussion of an ethics code at the board’s education retreat in December. He argued that though the meeting was properly noticed, it was held 150 miles outside of the district, and that the meeting agenda that was published never mentioned discussion of a proposed ethics code.

“There is no notice of a business meeting in this notice,” Clifford said. “Even if it was part of the education seminar, it was not part of the minutes, not part of the notice. They didn’t even put it on the agenda that they were going to talk about (the ethics code). This is an absolutely egregious violation of the open meetings act.”

He argued that this was a violation of the Open Public Meetings Act because they had a business discussion and created new policy which was later passed without discussion at the board’s Dec. 17 meeting.

But Valley’s attorney disputed that point.

“It is clear that it was an open public meeting,” Berman said. “There’s no substantive violation much less an intentional violation by Mr. Jacobson.”

Berman, in representing the hospital, said there are concerns this recall petition could discourage other qualified candidates from running for the hospital board.

“It would deter people from serving,” Berman said. “It would cause them to second guess others and it would cause administrative workings to grind to a halt.”

He also asserted that Clifford’s suggestion that the open meetings act be strictly interpreted was not meeting with the spirit and intent of the law.

“There’s nothing in the bylaws or the Open Public Meeting Act that states they should be interpreted strictly,” Berman said.

Clifford also took issue with Jacobson’s alleged unauthorized unilateral creation of a subcommittee as well as statements made regarding a closed-door review of the state Public Disclosure Commission’s investigation into campaign finance violations in 2005 and 2006 for which Valley CEO Rich Roodman later agreed to pay fines.

“Don Jacobson has served on school boards,” Clifford said. “He’s served on this board for many years. He knows the open meetings law. It is a duty of the president to know his powers.”

Berman refuted Clifford’s arguments.

“There is nothing in the facts presented by Mr. Clifford that shows there was (malicious intent),” Berman said.

In order for the recall petition to be considered sufficient, Clifford was required to prove a prima facie case, or establish enough facts to support the petition. Trickey is not supposed to determine the truth of facts provided.

If the recall petition is found sufficient, Clifford will have 180 days to collect more than 14,000 signatures, which would then have the recall go to ballot.

The last successful recall in the county was in 2004.

More in News

Sarah Abdullah is a pharmacist who left Iraq as a refugee. She joined the Welcome Back Center at Highline College and is now only two tests away from gaining Washington state certification to practice her trade. Aaron Kunkler/staff photo
Recredentialed: Barriers face Washington’s immigrant, refugee professionals

Even with degrees from abroad, it can be difficult for many to get certified in the state.

If passed, Senate Bill 6254 would limit the nicotine concentration of vape products, ban certain flavoring chemicals and require vape manufacturers, distributors and retailers to obtain licenses from the Washington State Liquor and Cannabis Board. File photo
Lawmakers propose sweeping regulations for vaping industry

Bill supporters cite concerns over health issues and teen use.

Photo by Haley Ausbun. A cloudy day at Renton Municipal Airport.
Seaplane pilots, businesses say no to FAA plans

Local businesses and pilots ask Renton to reconsider airport master plan

A proposal by Senate Democrats would require concealed pistol license applicants in Washington state to complete a safety course. File photo
Democrats seek firearm training requirement for concealed carriers

Republican senator calls proposal ‘unconstitutional.’

Snohomish County man is first U.S. case of new coronavirus

A man in his 30s was hospitalized in Everett after contracting the virus during a trip to China.

Photo courtesy of city of Renton. Council President Ruth Pérez speaks at Centro Rendu de San Vicente de Paul for the Reyes Magos event.
Census campaign joins Reyes Magos celebration

Members of Renton’s Hispanic community gathered Jan. 10 at Centro Rendu de… Continue reading

Alexander, who attended the event with his family that are currently housed at Mary’s Place, shows off his new shoes, compared to the pair he’s had the last two years. The shoes were just one of the resources his family accessed at the United Way Family Resource Exchange on Martin Luther King Jr. Day, Jan. 20 at Lindbergh High School.
MLK’s humanity reflected in resource fair

United Way host Family Resource Exchange event

Photo courtesy of Carol Kaelson. Christel Tucker, a Renton resident and flight attendant, stands at the wheel at Wheel of Fortune. Her episode airs Monday, Jan. 20.
Rentonite spins the wheel of her dreams

Local finds herself winning thousands on Wheel of Fortune

Matt Marshall, leader of the Washington Three Percenters gun rights group, addresses a crowd rallying for Second Amendment rights Jan. 17 at the state Capitol in Olympia. Marshall condemned Republican leadership in the House of Representatives, which expelled Rep. Matt Shea from the Republican Caucus. Marshall announced his candidacy for the 2nd District seat held by House Minority Leader J.T. Wilcox. Photo by Cameron Sheppard, WNPA News Service
Gun rights advocates rally at Capitol

Criticism levied at Matt Shea investigation, Republican leadership.

Most Read