Courtesy of the EPA. A photo of one of the test wells at the Quendall Terminals site.

Courtesy of the EPA. A photo of one of the test wells at the Quendall Terminals site.

EPA to start cleanup on Quendall Terminals

Landowner cites concerns about clean up time

Most don’t think about creosote, oil and arsenic when thinking about Lake Washington, except for the folks working on cleaning up a hazardous site in Renton’s Kennydale neighborhood that includes parts of the shore and lake.

After years of deliberation and analysis, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is putting the final touches on the cleanup plan for the 51-acre Quendall Terminals site along Lake Washington — one of the largest unused stretches of the shore left, next to the Seahawk’s training center, Virginia Mason Athletic Center. The site is contaminated by years of storage and spills from hazardous materials, which spreads and will continue to slowly spread until cleanup is complete.

Once the site is cleaned, Quendall property owners hope a developer will build a large development with housing, retail and restaurants, as well as a small park area along the water. But the owners’ believe the EPA’s preferred cleanup plan will make the development of the site infeasible.

The 22-acres of land is contaminated with oil, creosote and coal tars that are in liquid form, known as a dense non-aqueous phase liquid (DNAPL). This contamination then leaches out of the DNAPL and into the groundwater. The 29-acre lake portion of the site has contaminated sediment, seven to 16 feet below the water from creosote, oil and coal spills. The groundwater also spreads the contamination where people and aquatic life can be exposed to it on the site. The lake area of contamination has not changed much and onshore some of the contaminants flow slowly but much is stuck in the soil and “generally does not move,” according to the EPA.

Quendall had a creosote manufacturer from 1916 to 1969. After that, it became a crude oil, waste oil and diesel oil storage site before also becoming a log storage site. That ended in 2009 and the site has since been vacant, with signs and gates warning passersby of the hazards on the site. Other than the creosote oil contamination, naturally occurring arsenic was released into the groundwater as a reaction to the DNAPL.

Quendall was added to the EPA’s Superfund National Priorities List, which guides clean up for the most contaminated sites in the U.S., back in 2006. It was then put on an Administrator’s Emphasis List in 2017. In an interview with KNKX in 2018, one of the property owners Robert Cugini had hoped the expedited process would mean sooner development.

Cugini has been working on getting Quendall redeveloped for over 35 years when he worked with his dad on the property. For almost 25 years, the state Department of Ecology was monitoring the hazards on the site and determining cleanup, until the EPA took over and restarted the process, at the Department of Ecology’s request.

The EPA originally preferred an alternative that would use, along with capping the soil, in situ solidification (ISS) which mixes materials like cement into the soil to solidify contaminants and keep them from spreading. In 2017, EPA decided to include a new technology in the alternatives, Self-Sustaining Technology for Active Remediation (STAR,) which creates an underground self-sustained combustion, and flamelessly heats up the contaminants, leaving carbon dioxide and water in its stead. They then took one year to test STAR at the Quendall site.

In a one-page outline about concerns of the EPA’s plan for Quendall from Robert Cugini, it states: “After more than 15 years of environmental studies, EPA determined there were several options that are less disruptive to the neighborhood but have decided to ask the public to agree with their decision to experiment with technology that is not proven on a large-scale project.”

Although Cugini is concerned about the EPA’s preferred alternative, he has worked with the agency for many years and said they do not have a contentious or adversarial relationship over the disagreement. Both groups, he said, want to see this site cleaned up.

The value of the cleanup in the EPA’s alternative is greater than the land, and feasibility depends on who pays for it, Cugini said. There are several other financially responsible parties, including Puget Sound Energy and Burlington Northern Railroad and the state Department of Natural Resources. EPA determines how cleanup is paid for.

He also said that his family purchased the land after the contamination and are not responsible for it. The creosote operation company Vertellus (successor of Reilly Tar and Chemical) filed for bankruptcy in 2016, citing many factors including high debt and environmental burdens. He wants development to pay a significant portion of the cleanup costs, so time plays a factor in their payment plan. The property owners have been responsible for the costs of studies on the Quendall site, and paying EPA to assess the results.

The EPA’s study of the STAR technology treating sections of Quendall found it had a 99 percent reduction in contaminants, according to a presentation delivered to Renton City Council in 2018.

Cugini believes the owner-preferred alternative, which was eliminated from consideration by EPA because it did not meet the objective of restoring groundwater, can actually be done quicker and cheaper. The owners also argue that no matter which plan is chosen, the groundwater will never be clean.

In a memorandum on the feasibility plan that suggests exploring STAR, EPA’s Kathryn Cerise states that the addition of the technology to the preferred alternative was estimated to not increase costs. The memorandum also states that ISS could potentially cause remaining contaminated groundwater to “pond” on the site, and possibly flow north or south of Quendall. The document also lists the concerns about STAR, as an emerging technology, and the fact it has a sole-source supplier.

Cugini also talked about those listed concerns and said that STAR is experimental and only available from one vendor. His team’s technical consultant also believes there are more worries with the effectiveness. The owners’ technical consultant Tim Flynn, who is with Aspect Consulting that did the first set of evaluations of alternatives, was at the proposed plan’s open house and public comment. At the open house, Flynn said STAR won’t be appropriate for the thin layers of contamination.

Cugini also says that, according to his consultant, the time STAR development will take is likely to be longer than EPA estimates. The only large site using STAR, a 37-acre former coal tar facility in Newark, New Jersey, started cleanup in 2014 and is still on-going, according to the website of STAR’s supplier.

EPA’s preferred cleanup plan calls for a second treatment, if STAR is not fully successful, using ISS. Cugini said that uncertainty in the timeline of cleanup makes it hard to pitch to potential developers.

“People are tired of talking about doing things and want something to happen on the site. How long is it going to take to start cleaning it up?” Cugini said. “I hope to see a successful, completed project. I hope to continue to work with EPA and other parties to make it happen.”

The EPA expects to issue a final cleanup decision in 2020. More plan documents and information are available at EPA’s website here, and in hard copy at the Downtown Renton Library.

Public comment for the plan is being accepted until Nov. 8, after being extended by the EPA, and can be emailed to cerise.kathryn@epa.gov or mailed to:

Kathryn Cerise, 12-d12-1

U.S. EPA Region 10

1200 Sixth Ave., Suite 155

Seattle WA 98101


Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing editor@rentonreporter.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.rentonreporter.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

Courtesy of the EPA. A photo of the old Quendall Terminals building on the site.

Courtesy of the EPA. A photo of the old Quendall Terminals building on the site.

Courtesy of the EPA. A photo of one of the test wells at the Quendall Terminals site.

Courtesy of the EPA. A photo of one of the test wells at the Quendall Terminals site.

Courtesy of the EPA. A photo of the old Quendall Terminals building on the site.

Courtesy of the EPA. A photo of the old Quendall Terminals building on the site.

More in News

Virtual town halls coming up for unincorporated King County

Events throughout September and October via Zoom will cater to different areas of the region.

A vacant building that went up in flames Aug. 27 at the corner of Pacific Highway S. and S. 279th St. in Federal Way. Fire investigators declared the blaze to be an arson. Photo courtesy of South King Fire Commissioner Bill Fuller
Renton man possibly connected to Federal Way arsons

Officers found several lighters and butane fuel in his possession while arresting the man on Aug. 28.

Stock photo
Renton woman pleads guilty to purchasing firearms for ‘violent street gangs’

According to case records, a 41-year-old Renton woman provided the guns to her son, who modified them and sold them to gang members

Seven decades later, the search for two missing Navy pilots continues

The pilots are thought to have disappeared near Black Lake, northeast of North Bend.

A view of the Palmer Fire, located seven miles southwest of Oroville in north central Washington. Source: InciWeb
Antifa isn’t starting Washington wildfires

Online conspiracy theories are spreading as the West Coast burns.

Courtesy King County Metro.
Metro bus route changes in Renton coming Sept. 19

As part of a plan to increase mobility between several South King County cities, Metro has added a new route and increased the frequency of other routes.

The truck of the Renton family as it was found Tuesday. While fleeing the Cold Springs Fire two adults were severely burned and one toddler died. Courtesy photo/Okanogan Sheriff’s Office
Toddler killed as Renton family flees Cold Springs Fire

The parents were severely burned and are being treated at Harborview Medical Center

A plane drops fire retardant on the Palmer Mountain Fire last week. The fire is listed as 84 percent contained, and fully lined. Laura Knowlton/Sound Publishing staff photo
Threat multiplier: How climate change, coronavirus and weather are scorching WA

Dry summer conspired with the pandemic and a wind storm.

Most Read