It fell from a book | POINT OF REVIEW

Recommendation: 4/5 Stars, SHOWTIME

Plot: When Lee Israel falls out of step with current tastes, she turns her art form to deception. An adaptation of the memoir, “Can You Ever Forgive Me?”, the true story of best-selling celebrity biographer Lee Israel.

Review: “Can You Ever Forgive Me?” is flying under the radar and really deserves more attention than it is receiving. Featuring Melissa McCarthy as down on her luck biographer Lee Israel, this is a film about a woman dedicated to her craft but desperate to make it any way she can.

Melissa McCarthy is brilliant in this film and without a doubt worthy of an Oscar nomination. In this role, she makes us believe in a struggling author passionate about unpopular topics. With this love affair, comes exhaustion, disappointment, and an opportunity to survive; all of which McCarthy embodies with near perfection. Her brilliance really begins to shine when doing some research for a book a letter from a literary giant falls from the pages. This original letter garners big bucks on the auction and private collector circuit. This gives Israel an idea and McCarthy a chance to show her range.

You will spend much of the second act of this movie wondering if our recluse will be caught. For their part, the filmmakers do a good job of slowly unwrapping the inevitable. Lee is playing with fire and we all know that she will be burned. As an audience member, we wrestle with the tension of how it will all come crashing down because when it does it is sure to be glorious.

The crash comes in the form of the FBI and a remorseful Lee admitting guilt. Judgment from the court doesn’t necessarily turn out the way one would envision but provides McCarthy an opportunity to deliver the monologue which will lead to her being nominated. It is this scene and what occurs afterward that sealed the deal for me. I think it will do the same for you; which is why I am recommending you see this one in theaters.

Be good to each other.

To read more reviews from Nathan Box visit his blog.

Talk to us

Please share your story tips by emailing

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) Please keep letters to 300 words or less.

More in Life

Auburn Symphony Orchestra announces 2020-21 season

Begins with Summer Series scheduled to start June 21

Medic One Foundation’s Gratitude Meals offer support to first responders, local businesses

The initiative provides hearty lunches to first responders staffing the COVID-19 testing sites as they work to test their colleagues.

‘Don’t assume it can’t happen to you’

Federal Way resident Evelyn Allcorn shares story of her husband’s battle with COVID-19 after he tested positive on March 28.

Auburn dance studio finds creative solutions to keep going during COVID-19

Pacific Ballroom Dance moves to online classes; group returned home early from national competition

Photo by Haley Ausbun
                                Boon Boona Coffee in downtown Renton is well-known for its large cafe space, but owner Efrem Fesaha has found a creative way to keep people to to-go orders only, putting a table right at the door. The order from the Governor hasn’t been easy for small businesses in Renton, and many are just taking it day to day and hoping for financial relief from local and regional leaders.
Renton communities reach out during shut-in

Local organizations, volunteers and businesses try to make the best of quarantine

Renton and AARP team up for seniors

New fitness park to funded and will open late in the summer

Schindler’s legacy bounces along at Baden

CEO of Baden Sports died unexpectedly in February

Renton March 2020 Youth of the Month
March Rotary Youth of the Month

Rotary members recognize three Renton School District high school students each month… Continue reading

Courtesy of HLN. A screenshot from a preview of an episode of a new true crime show that highlights the Ingrid Lyne case, where a Renton mother was murdered.
Infamous Renton crime to make TV debut

It’s been over two years since a man was found guilty for… Continue reading

Photos courtesy of Linda Smith
Celebrating Black Excellence

Local organization honors Black History Month

Alyx Chamberlain, Jennifer Keil and Mario Pilapil, courtesy of Rotary Club of Renton.
Teachers of the Month for February

As part of their commitment to education, and to celebrate teachers in… Continue reading

Photo by Haley Ausbun
                                During halftime, athletes and coaches have individual meetings, while parents watch a video prepared by Highlands Community Church for whatever biblical principle teams are learning about that week at the Upward sports league.
Sports that help kids grow

Local church league gives to neighborhood