Arguments made in hospital recall petition

Whether a petition to recall the president of the Valley Medical Center Board of Commissioners would move forward was argued Thursday for about an hour, but the judge indicated he wouldn’t issue his ruling until Tuesday (yesterday).

  • Friday, May 30, 2008 2:52pm
  • News


Whether a petition to recall the president of the Valley Medical Center Board of Commissioners would move forward was argued Thursday for about an hour, but the judge indicated he wouldn’t issue his ruling until Tuesday (yesterday).

King County Superior Judge Michael Trickey presided over what’s known as a “sufficiency hearing”.

Chris Clifford of Renton filed the petition against board President Don Jabcobson. Clifford stated that Jacobson had violated the Open Public Meetings Act and abused his power as president of the board by circumventing its bylaws.

Jacobson’s attorney, Scott Johnson, argued that the entirety of the recall petition was without merit and not worth wasting the court’s time discussing.

David Berman, an attorney from the firm of Perkins Cooie retained to represent the hospital, was granted a motion to intervene on behalf of Valley but was limited to narrow scope of argument.

Clifford pointed to the discussion of an ethics code at the board’s education retreat in December. He argued that though the meeting was properly noticed, it was held 150 miles outside of the district, and that the meeting agenda that was published never mentioned discussion of a proposed ethics code.

“There is no notice of a business meeting in this notice,” Clifford said. “Even if it was part of the education seminar, it was not part of the minutes, not part of the notice. They didn’t even put it on the agenda that they were going to talk about (the ethics code). This is an absolutely egregious violation of the open meetings act.”

He argued that this was a violation of the Open Public Meetings Act because they had a business discussion and created new policy which was later passed without discussion at the board’s Dec. 17 meeting.

But Valley’s attorney disputed that point.

“It is clear that it was an open public meeting,” Berman said. “There’s no substantive violation much less an intentional violation by Mr. Jacobson.”

Berman, in representing the hospital, said there are concerns this recall petition could discourage other qualified candidates from running for the hospital board.

“It would deter people from serving,” Berman said. “It would cause them to second guess others and it would cause administrative workings to grind to a halt.”

He also asserted that Clifford’s suggestion that the open meetings act be strictly interpreted was not meeting with the spirit and intent of the law.

“There’s nothing in the bylaws or the Open Public Meeting Act that states they should be interpreted strictly,” Berman said.

Clifford also took issue with Jacobson’s alleged unauthorized unilateral creation of a subcommittee as well as statements made regarding a closed-door review of the state Public Disclosure Commission’s investigation into campaign finance violations in 2005 and 2006 for which Valley CEO Rich Roodman later agreed to pay fines.

“Don Jacobson has served on school boards,” Clifford said. “He’s served on this board for many years. He knows the open meetings law. It is a duty of the president to know his powers.”

Berman refuted Clifford’s arguments.

“There is nothing in the facts presented by Mr. Clifford that shows there was (malicious intent),” Berman said.

In order for the recall petition to be considered sufficient, Clifford was required to prove a prima facie case, or establish enough facts to support the petition. Trickey is not supposed to determine the truth of facts provided.

If the recall petition is found sufficient, Clifford will have 180 days to collect more than 14,000 signatures, which would then have the recall go to ballot.

The last successful recall in the county was in 2004.

More in News

Halau Hula Ka Lei Mokihana I Ka Ua Noe perform at the 10th annual Uwajimaya Renton Polynesian Festival, Saturday Aug. 17. Photo by Haley Ausbun.
Celebrate culture with music, food and dance

The 10th annual Uwajimaya Renton Polynesian Festival was held Saturday Aug. 17,… Continue reading

Scott Kreidermacher, left, and Lara Randolph, right, hold up the food that remains from a busy day at the Free Grocery Store, a new project from nonprofit Sustainable Renton, on Monday, Aug. 19. Photo by Haley Ausbun.
Free grocery store to combat food waste

A small Renton nonprofit hopes to help homeless and keep food from the landfill

Melissa Glenn, hired in April 2019, is building the new social worker program at King County libraries “from the ground up.” Photo by Haley Ausbun.
Meeting those in-need where they congregate, the library

New library social worker is making swift, positive changes to lingering residents in need

Courtesy of Mary’s Place. Volunteers from KeyBank’s Hispanic-Latino Impact Networking Group and Key Women’s Network gave a formerly homeless family “everything they would need to start fresh in a new apartment” through the Make-a-Home program.
Volunteers needed to help displaced families

A mother and her children found a home in Renton thanks to Mary’s Place nonprofit

Staff, council scrap city-wide 20 mph plan

Neighborhoods can still request lower limits

Buses moving out of downtown

A new transit center may spur affordable home construction

From the Renton Reporter archives. The city has been sitting on the old Kaynan hangars, waiting to determine whether they’ll be demolished and reconstructed after the Airport Master Plan.
Councilmember sees loss of airport grant as a opportunity

Tricky airport planning is taking longer than expected, risking a $100K grant

Photo by Haley Ausbun. Seniors in nearby care facilities took flight in a 1942 Boeing Stearman biplane at Renton Municipal Airport, offered by Ageless Aviation Dreams Foundation.
No age cap to fly

On Sunday, Aug. 11 and Monday Aug. 12 seniors from Burien, Mercer… Continue reading

Most Read